Squishy Bun · Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Crazy Aaron's Better Butter
$35
See it on ebayThe full catalog
Squishy Fidget Value List
Every squishy fidget toy we track, with current resale values — updated daily. 4,627 variants across 230 brands; filter by brand or rarity, sort by resale value, and share any view by its URL.
Showing 529–576 of 4,627 squishies
Nee-DohUncommon
NeeDoh Galactic Glow Dream Drop Squishy Fidget Toy Nebula Haze
$35
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Crazy Aaron's Scaredy Cat Thinking Putty
$35
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Playful Puppy Thinking Putty with 5 Minis
$35
See it on ebay
Sunny DaysStandard
Butter and Peach Squeeezy Squishy Set
$35
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyRare
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Rare Set
$35
See it on ebay
Squishy FidgetStandard
Squishy Squeeezy Chicken
$35
See it on ebay
Nee-Doh · Nice BergUncommon
Nee-Doh Nice Berg Swirl
$35
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
NeeDoh JellySquish Squishy Fidget Toy Blue
$35
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
NeeDoh Groovy Fruit Squishy Fidget Toy Multicolor
$35
See it on ebay
RMSRare
RMS Invisible Maltose Mystery Big Bao Bun 7" Dumpling Squishy Fidget Toy
$34.99
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyUncommon
Thinking Putty - Robins Egg Limited Edition
$34.99
See it on ebay
Squishmallows · Squishmallows DisneyUncommon
Squishmallow Disney Lilo and Stitch Snow Cone Plush
$34.99
See it on ebay
Crazy Fun · Mystery DumplingRare
Crazy Fun Golden Ticket Edition Mystery Squishy Dumpling
$34.99
See it on ebay
RMSRare
RMS Mystery 3-Pack Bao Bun Dumpling Squishy Fidget Toys
$34.99
See it on ebay
PinkPinkSquishyStandard
GIANT Squishy Paw Stress Relief Decompression Toy w/ Flocking
$34.99
See it on ebay
Nee-DohRare
Schylling Nee-Doh Nice Cube Pepsi
$34.99
See it on ebay
Nee-Doh · Nee DohStandard
Nee Doh Pink Jelly Sparkle Jellyfish Squishy
$34.99
See it on ebay
Taba · Taba BakeryStandard
Taba Bakery Jam Mochi Squishy Bundle
$34.99
See it on ebay
Taba · Taba Pastel DessertStandard
Taba Pastel Dessert Squishy Bundle
$34.99
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
Nee-Doh Color Changing Stress Balls Lot of 3
$34.99
See it on ebay
Squishy FidgetUncommon
Glitter Dumpling Squishy Mystery Box 10 Color Random 2026 Edition
$34.99
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyUncommon
Jingle Limited Edition Thinking Putty
$34.99
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyUncommon
Super Fly Limited Edition Thinking Putty
$34.99
See it on ebay
Nee-Doh · Nice BergUncommon
Nee-Doh Nice Berg Blue Ice Cube
$34.99
See it on ebay
RMSRare
RMS Color Change Mystery Big Bao Bun 7" Dumpling Squishy Fidget Toy
$34.99
See it on ebay
Nee-Doh · Nice Berg SwirlUncommon
Nee-Doh Nice Berg Swirl XL - Orange Yellow
$34.99
See it on ebay
Squishy FidgetStandard
Squeezy Butter Banana Apple Squishy Bundle
$34.99
See it on ebay
Squishy Bun · Mystery DumplingStandard
Mystery Dumpling Mini Squishy Bun Series 1
$34.99
See it on ebay
Squishy Fidget · Cube SquishyStandard
Glitter Cube Squishy
$34.82
See it on ebay
Mystery DumplingRare
Ultimate Mystery Dumpling Collector's Bundle 3-Piece
$34.62
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
Nee-Doh Big Lot of 7 Assorted Squishy Toys
$34.50
See it on ebay
Squishy Bun · Mystery DumplingUncommon
Crazy Fun Mystery Dumpling Squishy Bun - Starlight Edition
$34.29
See it on ebay
Taba · Taba Mochi Tiny SquishiesStandard
ORB Taba Mochi Tiny Squishies 15-Pack
$34.29
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
NeeDoh Super Groovy Glob Squishy Fidget Toy
$34
See it on ebay
SquishmallowsStandard
Squishmallow Pokemon Pikachu 14" Plush
$34
See it on ebay
PinkPinkSquishyStandard
Wholesale Only-1000g Liquid Squishy Silicone Kit, No Odor, for Squishy Toy Making
$34
See it on ebay
Big SquijStandard
Big Squij Jumbo Pumpkin Squishy
$34
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
Nee-Doh Jelly Squish Sparkle Jellyfish
$34
See it on ebay
PinkPinkSquishyStandard
Wholesale Only-1000g Transparent Liquid Squishy Silicone Kit, No Odor, for Squishy Toy Making
$34
See it on ebay
TabaStandard
Bear Taba Squishy Sensory Experience Pack
$33.99
See it on ebay
TabaStandard
Ice Cube Taba Squishy Sensory Experience Pack
$33.99
See it on ebay
Squishy Bun · Crazy FunUncommon
Crazy Fun Mystery Dumpling Super Mega Rainbow Blind Pack
$33.25
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
Dumpling Squishy
$33.25
See it on ebay
Squishmallows · MallowmeesStandard
Squishmallows Mallowmees Bubba & Elle Bundle
$33.08
See it on ebay
Squishy FidgetUncommon
Viral Purple Holographic Squishy Dumpling Bun
$33
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
Nee-Doh DohNut Squishy Stress Ball Sugar Donut Blue
$33
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
NeeDoh Nice-sicle Popsicle Squishy Fidget Toy
$33
See it on ebayeBay links are affiliate links — SquishyTrade may earn a commission on qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.