Squishy BunUncommon
Squishy Bun The Original Mystery Dumpling Shark Edition Blind Box 2x Lot
$750
See it on ebayThe full catalog
Squishy Fidget Value List
Every squishy fidget toy we track, with current resale values — updated daily. 3,713 variants across 181 brands; filter by brand or rarity, sort by resale value, and share any view by its URL.
Showing 1–48 of 3,713 squishies
Nee-DohStandard
NeeDoh Smiley Face Press-Doh Squishy Fidget Toy
$699
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
NeeDoh Stars and Moon Press-Doh Squishy Fidget Toy
$575
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
NeeDoh Heart Spiral Press-Doh Squishy Fidget Toy
$550
See it on ebay
Nee-DohRare
Nee-Doh Ginger Glowman
$520
See it on ebay
Nee-DohUncommon
NeeDoh Color Change set of 3 Squishy Fidget Toy
$498
See it on ebay
Squishy Fidget · Mystery DumplingUncommon
Mystery Bun Dumpling Rainbow Squishy
$480
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
24K Real Gold |Thinking Putty
$400
See it on ebay
Squishy BunUncommon
Squishy Bun Super Mega Rainbow Mystery Squishy "Dumpling" (Glitter Version) Blind Box 4x Lot
$400
See it on ebay
Nee-Doh · Nice CubeUncommon
Nee-Doh Nice Cube Dr Pepper Lot of 22
$396
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
NeeDoh Dippin Dazzer Egg Squishy Fidget Toy Smooth Sunrise
$395
See it on ebay
Mystery DumplingUncommon
Mystery Dumpling Series 18 Sherbert Collection
$350
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
Nee-Doh Authentic Bundle
$341.26
See it on ebay
Crazy Fun · Mystery DumplingStandard
Mystery Mini Glitter Dumpling (Pack of 48)
$339.99
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
Giant Squishy Lot - Nee-Doh, Speks, Crazy Aaron's
$315.87
See it on ebay
Squishy BunChase
Squishy Bun The Original Mystery Dumpling Galaxy Dumpling Chase
$300
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
NeeDoh Wild Cats Squishy Fidget Toy Set of 5 Pink/ Orange/ Blue/ Green/ Purple
$259
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
NeeDoh Happy Snappy Ball Squishy Fidget Toy Green
$250
See it on ebay
Squishy BunUncommon
Squishy Bun Mystery Squishy "Dumpling" - Pink Halographic Glitter Bun Toy
$249
See it on ebay
Nee-DohUncommon
NeeDoh Polar Glow Penguin Squishy Fidget Toy
$230
See it on ebay
Squishy Fidget · DumplingChase
Squishy Dumpling Green Apple Holographic Chase
$199.99
See it on ebay
Mystery DumplingUncommon
Mystery Squishy Dumpling 12-Pack Bundle
$199.99
See it on ebay
Squishy BunChase
Squishy Bun Rainbow Mystery Squishy "Dumpling" (Simmering Starlight Chase Version) Blind Box 4x Lot
$199
See it on ebay
Squishy BunUncommon
Squishy Bun The Original Mystery Dumpling-Sugar Bear Edition Blind Box
$197
See it on ebay
SquishmallowsRare
Squishmallow x Pokemon Gengar 12 Inch Pokemon Center Exclusive Plush
$193
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
Nee-Doh Fuzz Ball Flower Power
$179.99
See it on ebay
Nee-Doh · Rainbow MysteryUncommon
Nee-Doh Rainbow Mystery Dumpling
$168
See it on ebay
Crazy FunRare
Crazy Fun Mystery Dumpling Tie Dye Edition Full Case
$165
See it on ebay
MellowSquishStandard
(Fully Booked Out) Customise Large Squishy Fidget(30 Days to make)
$161
See it on ebay
Nee-Doh · Nice CubeStandard
Nee-Doh Nice Cube Stress Ball
$160
See it on ebay
Squishy BunUncommon
Squishy Bun Mystery Squishy "Dumpling" - Shimmering Starlight Bun Toy
$159
See it on ebay
Squishy BunUncommon
Squishy Bun Mystery Squishy "Dumpling" - Gold Glitter Bun Toy
$159
See it on ebay
Squishy BunUncommon
Squishy Bun Mystery Squishy "Dumpling" - Pink Glitter Bun Toy
$159
See it on ebay
Squishy BunChase
Squishy Bun Rainbow Mystery Squishy "Dumpling" (Tie Dye Chase Version) Blind Box
$155
See it on ebay
Squishy FidgetStandard
Fidget Toy Bundle
$153.42
See it on ebay
Mystery DumplingStandard
Jumbo Mystery Squishy Dumpling Bun
$150
See it on ebay
Mystery Dumpling · Crazy Fun Mystery DumplingRare
Crazy Fun Mystery Dumpling Starlight Glitter
$150
See it on ebay
Nee-Doh · Nice Ice BabyStandard
Nee-Doh Nice Ice Baby Tactile Squishy Set
$150
See it on ebay
SquishmallowsStandard
Squishmallow Pokemon Gengar & Pikachu 14" Plush Set
$150
See it on ebay
Viral Crazy Fun · Mystery DumplingUncommon
Giant Mystery Dumpling Squishy
$149.99
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
Schylling Nee-Doh Mix Lot Multicolor Squishy Fidget Toys
$149.97
See it on ebay
Squishy BunUncommon
Squishy Bun Charming Mystery Squishy "Dumpling" (Pink Glitter) Blind Box
$148
See it on ebay
Squishy BunChase
Squishy Bun Rainbow Mystery Squishy "Dumpling" (Galaxy Glitter Gel Chase Version) Blind Box 4x Lot
$146
See it on ebay
Nee-Doh · Glowy GhostRare
Glowy Ghost Green Glow-in-the-Dark Squishy
$143.50
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
NeeDoh Groovy Jewel Squishy Fidget Toy Blue
$140
See it on ebay
Squishy Bun · Mystery DumplingChase
Mystery Dumpling Super Mega Jumbo Rainbow Squishy
$140
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
Nee Doh Squishmas 2026 Advent Calendar
$139.991.6× retail
See it on ebay
TABASQUISHYStandard
Customizing Squishy Toy
$139
See it on ebayeBay links are affiliate links — SquishyTrade may earn a commission on qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.