Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyRare
Thinking Putty - Holiday Original Retired Colors
$600
See it on ebayThe full catalog
Squishy Fidget Value List
Every squishy fidget toy we track, with current resale values — updated daily. 4,627 variants across 230 brands; filter by brand or rarity, sort by resale value, and share any view by its URL.
Showing 1–48 of 117 (filtered from 4,627)
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyRare
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Neon Flash Jumbo
$246.92
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyGrail
Thinking Putty Mistletoe Madness
$102.60
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Crazy Aaron's Scentsory Putty Lot (11 Tins)
$100
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Series Thinking Putty Bundle
$84.64
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyGrail
Thinking Putty Electric Green
$77.90
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyGrail
Thinking Putty Snow Angel
$76
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyGrail
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Gelt
$72.20
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyGrail
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty - Emerald Sky (Hypercolor & Glow)
$72
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Santa's Reindeer Advent Calendar
$67
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Collection
$57.95
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyRare
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Valentines Collection
$54.15
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Mini Tin Lot
$50
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyRare
Liberty Bell Limited Edition Thinking Putty
$49.99
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyRare
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Mostly Ghostly
$49
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyUncommon
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Lost Treasure Guardians Complete Set
$49
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Mini Tins Variety Pack
$47.99
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Butter & You're Purr-fect
$46.50
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyRare
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Play It Forward
$45
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyUncommon
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Lost Treasure Guardians 10-Piece Set
$44.10
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyGrail
Thinking Putty AURA Glow in the Dark
$38.40
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyRare
Crazy Aaron's Bubble Yum 2-in-1 Scentsory Putty
$35.10
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyUncommon
Better Butter Thinking Putty - Intergalactic
$35
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Super Fly 3.2 oz
$35
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Crazy Aaron's Scaredy Cat Thinking Putty
$35
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Playful Puppy Thinking Putty with 5 Minis
$35
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyRare
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Rare Set
$35
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyUncommon
Thinking Putty - Robins Egg Limited Edition
$34.99
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyUncommon
Jingle Limited Edition Thinking Putty
$34.99
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyUncommon
Super Fly Limited Edition Thinking Putty
$34.99
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Better Butter Berry
$30
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyRare
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Super Mega Rainbow Mystery
$30
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyUncommon
Jack O'Lantern Limited Edition Thinking Putty
$30
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Thinking Putty Set
$30
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyRare
Crazy Aaron's Better Delightful Dumpling Thinking Putty
$29.99
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyRare
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Primary Purple Vintage
$29
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyRare
Crazy Aaron's Valentine Thinking Putty Bears Limited Edition
$28
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyUncommon
Robins Egg Limited Edition Thinking Putty
$27.50
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Crazy Aaron's Jack O Lantern Thinking Putty
$27.50
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Crazy Aaron's North Star Thinking Putty
$27.50
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty - Mini Mystery Set of 3
$26
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty - Super Lava
$25.02
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyRare
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Ion Glow
$25
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Egg-Cellent Globby Yolk Ball
$25
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Crazy Aaron's Egg-Cellent Thinking Putty
$24.97
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Buttercream Thinking Putty
$24.01
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyUncommon
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Halloween Jack O Lantern
$22.99
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Crazy Aaron's Mini Thinking Putty Ion
$22.95
See it on ebayeBay links are affiliate links — SquishyTrade may earn a commission on qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.