Compare

Better Butter Thinking Putty vs Mixed Emotions Multicolor Thinking Putty: Which Is Worth More?

Better Butter Thinking Putty is currently worth more — about $19.99 versus $12.99 for Mixed Emotions Multicolor Thinking Putty. Compare current resale values, retail, rarity, and more below — values refresh daily.

MetricBetter Butter Thinking PuttyMixed Emotions Multicolor Thinking Putty
Resale value$19.99$12.99
Retail price
Resale vs retail
RarityStandardStandard
BrandCrazy Aaron'sCrazy Aaron's
Released

Browse & compare more squishies →