Squishy BunUncommon
Squishy Bun The Original Mystery Dumpling Shark Edition Blind Box 2x Lot
$750
See it on ebayValue guide
Most Valuable Squishies Right Now
Updated Jul 19, 2026 · values refresh daily
The squishy fidget toy market is dominated by NeeDoh and Mystery Bun Dumpling lines, with resale values ranging from $230 to $750 for top pieces. The highest-value items are typically multi-packs, blind box lots, and rare variants like the Shark Edition and Ginger Glowman, which command premium prices due to scarcity and collector demand.
Nee-DohStandard
NeeDoh Smiley Face Press-Doh Squishy Fidget Toy
$699
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
NeeDoh Stars and Moon Press-Doh Squishy Fidget Toy
$575
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
NeeDoh Heart Spiral Press-Doh Squishy Fidget Toy
$550
See it on ebay
Nee-DohRare
Nee-Doh Ginger Glowman
$520
See it on ebay
Nee-DohUncommon
NeeDoh Color Change set of 3 Squishy Fidget Toy
$498
See it on ebay
Squishy Fidget · Mystery DumplingUncommon
Mystery Bun Dumpling Rainbow Squishy
$480
See it on ebay
Squishy BunUncommon
Squishy Bun Super Mega Rainbow Mystery Squishy "Dumpling" (Glitter Version) Blind Box 4x Lot
$400
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
24K Real Gold |Thinking Putty
$400
See it on ebay
Nee-Doh · Nice CubeUncommon
Nee-Doh Nice Cube Dr Pepper Lot of 22
$396
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
NeeDoh Dippin Dazzer Egg Squishy Fidget Toy Smooth Sunrise
$395
See it on ebay
Mystery DumplingUncommon
Mystery Dumpling Series 18 Sherbert Collection
$350
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
Nee-Doh Authentic Bundle
$341.26
See it on ebay
Crazy Fun · Mystery DumplingStandard
Mystery Mini Glitter Dumpling (Pack of 48)
$339.99
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
Giant Squishy Lot - Nee-Doh, Speks, Crazy Aaron's
$315.87
See it on ebay
Squishy BunChase
Squishy Bun The Original Mystery Dumpling Galaxy Dumpling Chase
$300
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
NeeDoh Wild Cats Squishy Fidget Toy Set of 5 Pink/ Orange/ Blue/ Green/ Purple
$259
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
NeeDoh Happy Snappy Ball Squishy Fidget Toy Green
$250
See it on ebay
Squishy BunUncommon
Squishy Bun Mystery Squishy "Dumpling" - Pink Halographic Glitter Bun Toy
$249
See it on ebay
Nee-DohUncommon
NeeDoh Polar Glow Penguin Squishy Fidget Toy
$230
See it on ebayeBay links are affiliate links — SquishyTrade may earn a commission on qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
Frequently asked questions
What makes a squishy worth $750?
The Squishy Bun Mystery Dumpling Shark Edition 2x Lot reaches $750 resale due to its uncommon rarity classification and blind box format, which creates scarcity. Multi-pack lots and special editions like glitter or holographic variants consistently achieve the highest values in the current market.
Is the Nee-Doh Ginger Glowman rare?
Yes, the Nee-Doh Ginger Glowman is classified as rare and resells for $520, making it one of the most valuable single-item squishies. Its rarity designation places it above standard and uncommon pieces, reflecting genuine collector scarcity.
How are squishy resale values determined?
Resale values are based on rarity classification (standard, uncommon, rare, chase), item format (single vs. multi-pack lots), special variants (glitter, holographic, color-change), and blind box scarcity. These daily-refreshed prices reflect actual secondary market demand, not original retail cost.
What's the most valuable standard rarity squishy?
The NeeDoh Smiley Face Press-Doh Squishy Fidget Toy resells for $699 despite standard rarity, making it the highest-value non-rare item. This demonstrates that even standard pieces can achieve premium prices based on specific variants and collector interest.