Most Valuable Squishmallows

Licensed character collaborations—particularly Pokemon and Star Wars—command the highest resale values. The top item, the Pokemon Gengar & Pikachu 14" set, resells for $150, while standard character Squishmallows typically range from $25-$35. Size also matters; the 20" Baby Yoda plush is worth $98 compared to smaller versions of similar characters.

Interestingly, most top-value Squishmallows are classified as 'standard' rarity, including the $150 Gengar & Pikachu set and $98 Baby Yoda plush. Only a few items in the top 15 are marked 'rare,' suggesting resale value is driven more by character popularity and licensing appeal than scarcity.

Pokemon Squishmallows vary significantly by character and size. The Gengar & Pikachu 14" set reaches $150, the 10" Togepi is $75, the 10" Gengar & Pikachu standard version is $44, and the 10" Snorlax is $25. Licensed Pokemon collaborations consistently rank among the highest-value Squishmallows available.

These are current secondary market resale values refreshed daily, not original retail prices. They reflect what collectors are actually paying for these items on the resale market, which can be significantly higher than MSRP due to demand, limited availability, or discontinued status.