Most Valuable Squishmallows

The top-valued Squishmallows share common traits: Pokemon Center exclusivity (like the $193 Gengar or $86 Pikachu), larger sizes (20-24 inches), and limited-edition collaborations with major franchises like Star Wars and Sanrio. Standard retail releases typically resell for significantly less, even when they're the same character in different sizes.

Yes—the Squishmallow x Pokemon Gengar 12-inch is marked as rare and commands the highest resale value at $193. However, other high-value items like the $150 Gengar & Pikachu set are listed as standard rarity, suggesting that exclusivity and production limits matter more than official rarity designations for pricing.

Size significantly impacts value. The 20-inch Pokemon Gengar resells for $99, while the 12-inch Pokemon Center exclusive Gengar reaches $193—showing that exclusivity trumps size. Similarly, the 24-inch Snorlax is worth $99, but the 12-inch Pokemon Center exclusive Snorlax is valued at $73, demonstrating that retailer exclusivity drives premium pricing.

The Pokemon Center exclusive Gengar 12-inch is the #1 most valuable Squishmallow in this dataset at $193 USD resale value. The next tier includes the Gengar & Pikachu set ($150) and Malcom the Mushroom ($129), with values dropping sharply below $100 for most other collectibles.