SquishyTrade

Series value guide

Butter Squishy Value Guide

Every Butter Squishy squishy fidget variant we track, sorted by current resale value — most valuable first. 13 variants in this series, topping out around $99. Values and price history refresh daily so you always know what each one is really worth.

Filter & sort all Butter Squishy in the browser →

eBay links are affiliate links — SquishyTrade may earn a commission on qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Butter Squishy — frequently asked questions

How much is a Butter Squishy squishy worth?

Butter Squishy squishies range from about $6.17 to $99 on the resale market, with the It's Butter Slow Rising Squishy Set the most valuable at around $99. Values are sorted most-valuable-first above and refresh daily.

What is the rarest Butter Squishy squishy?

The rarest Butter Squishy we track is the Stitch Butter Squishy, rated uncommon in our catalog, currently reselling for around $16.24. Limited editions and discontinued colorways are the hardest to find and carry the biggest resale premiums.

Price alerts

Get squishy price alerts

Drop your email and we'll tell you when a squishy you're watching drops in price or comes back in stock. No spam — just the alerts you ask for.

Double opt-in — you'll get a confirmation email first, and can unsubscribe anytime.