Butter FoamStandard
Butter Foam Slow-Rise Squishies Fidget Toy
$19.99
See it on ebayThe full catalog
Squishy Fidget Value List
Every squishy fidget toy we track, with current resale values — updated daily. 3,885 variants across 187 brands; filter by brand or rarity, sort by resale value, and share any view by its URL.
Showing 961–1,008 of 3,885 squishies
Nee-DohStandard
Nee Doh Cool Cats Squishy Fidget Stress Ball Toys Colors Ship Assorted
$19.99
See it on ebay
PeachyBbiesStandard
PeachyBbies Novelty Slime Fidget Putty (7oz Jar) "Pastel Cloud Cake" Cloud Dough Slime
$19.99
See it on ebay
Squishmallows · SquooshemsStandard
Emily Vampire Bat Squooshems 3"
$19.99
See it on ebay
Squishy FidgetStandard
Mystery Squishy Dumplings
$19.99
See it on ebay
PeachyBbiesStandard
PeachyBbies Novelty Slime Fidget Putty (7oz Jar) "Rainbow Sherbet" Cloud Dough Slime
$19.99
See it on ebay
TabaStandard
Pufferfish Taba Squishy
$19.99
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
Nee Doh Sploot Splat Squishy Fidget Stress Ball Toy
$19.99
See it on ebay
CREAMY TREEStandard
【CT019】Strawberry Ice Cream Cone Squishy Toy
$19.99
See it on ebay
Squishy FidgetRare
Crazy Fun RMS Mystery Squishy Dumpling
$19.99
See it on ebay
Squishmallows · Original SquishmallowsUncommon
Squishmallows Tatiana Turquoise
$19.99
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
Nee Doh Teenie Cool Cats Squishy Fidget Stress Ball Toys Colors Ship Assorted
$19.99
See it on ebay
TabaStandard
Cute Basketball Taba Squishy
$19.99
See it on ebay
TabaStandard
Green Turtle Set Taba Squishy
$19.99
See it on ebay
Expressions RainbowStandard
Expressions Rainbow Squeeze Ball Fidget Toys – Colorful Stress Relief Sensory Squishy Set
$19.99
See it on ebay
TabaStandard
Classic Yellow Cheese Taba Squishy
$19.99
See it on ebay
Squishhy Bonbon-ShapedStandard
Squishhy Bonbon-Shaped Textured Squishies Fidget Stress Ball
$19.99
See it on ebay
TabaStandard
Boom Buddy Blind Bag Taba Squishy
$19.99
See it on ebay
PinkPinkSquishyStandard
Kitty Marshmallow Bundle Squishy Stress Relief Decompression Toy
$19.99
See it on ebay![[Blind Box] Shrimeow Squishy Toy (Non-Returnable After Unboxing)](/images/blind-box-shrimeow-squishy-toy-non-returnable-after-unboxing/0.webp)
CREAMY TREEStandard
[Blind Box] Shrimeow Squishy Toy (Non-Returnable After Unboxing)
$19.99
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
Nee Doh Teenie Hot Shots Sports Balls Squishy Fidget Toys
$19.99
See it on ebay
Sunny DaysStandard
Sunny Days Fresh Cheese Squishy
$19.99
See it on ebay
PinkPinkSquishyStandard
Fruit Juice Bear Squishy Stress Relief Decompression Toy
$19.99
See it on ebay
TabaStandard
Chill Cloud Blind Bag Taba Squishy
$19.99
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
Nee Doh Nice Cube Squishy Fidget Stress Ball
$19.99
See it on ebay
Nee-Doh · Nice Ice Cream ConeRare
NeeDoh Orange Nice Ice Cream Cone
$19.99
See it on ebay
SquishmallowsRare
SlimyGloop x Squishmallows Gelli Gels Stress Ball Squishy Fidget Toy
$19.99
See it on ebay
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyUncommon
Phantom Thinking Putty Glow-in-the-Dark
$19.99
See it on ebay
SquishmallowsStandard
Squishmallows Super Soft Plush Toys 8" Poppy Playtime Squad 2026 Character
$19.99
See it on ebay
Squishy FidgetStandard
Cheese Squishy Stress Ball Soft Squeeze Sensory Fidget Toy
$19.99
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
Nee Doh Ice Cream Cone Nice-Sicle Squishy
$19.99
See it on ebay
SquishmallowsStandard
Squishmallows Super Soft Plush Toys 10" Pokémon Squad - Gengar
$19.99
See it on ebay
TabaStandard
Transparent-purple Pufferfish Taba Squishy
$19.99
See it on ebay
TabaStandard
Flocked Cow Taba Squishy
$19.99
See it on ebay
SquishmallowsStandard
Squishmallows Super Soft Plush Toys 10" Pokémon Squad - Torchic
$19.99
See it on ebay
Nee-DohStandard
Nee Doh Teenie Fuzz Ball Squishy Fidget Toys
$19.99
See it on ebay
Nee-Doh · Nee DohStandard
Schylling Nee Doh Gummy Bear Squishy - Pink
$19.99
See it on ebay
TabaStandard
Blue-pink-yellow Cookie Sandwich Taba Squishy
$19.99
See it on ebay
TabaStandard
Purple-white Cookie Sandwich Sandwich Taba Squishy
$19.99
See it on ebay
TabaStandard
Flocked Brown Shar Pei Taba Squishy
$19.99
See it on ebay
TabaStandard
Cute Soccer Taba Squishy
$19.99
See it on ebay
TabaStandard
Happy Pop Blind Bag Taba Squishy
$19.99
See it on ebay
TabaStandard
Transparent Pufferfish Taba Squishy
$19.99
See it on ebay
SquishmallowsStandard
Squishmallows Super Soft Plush Toys 10" Pokémon Squad - Pikachu (Eyes Closed)
$19.99
See it on ebay
Squishy Fidget · Puffer AxolotlStandard
Puffer Axolotl Squishy - Pink
$19.99
See it on ebay
TabaStandard
Pink Pufferfish Taba Squishy
$19.99
See it on ebay
TabaStandard
Taba Jelly Squeeze Coffee Boba Tea Squishy
$19.99
See it on ebay
TabaStandard
Green Xmas Cookie Sandwich Taba Squishy
$19.99
See it on ebayeBay links are affiliate links — SquishyTrade may earn a commission on qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.